Reading Nonfiction Like a Detective - Grade 6

In this text, students will use the “detective” metaphor to guide them through a set of experiments in reading nonfiction. The notion of reading like a detective is based on assumptions about people and texts that can be summarized in the following way:

  • Human beings are symbol-using animals. We are always indicating, meaning otherwise or in addition to.

  • Texts, including images, ads, film, and television, are things people make that other people can read. These texts have multiple “levels” and, therefore, can be read in multiple ways.

The metaphor, as it is used in the unit, suggests that the habits and behaviors a detective employs to solve a crime—for example, asking questions, building (and rebuilding) theories based on evidence, doubting, mistrusting appearances—can also be usefully employed by readers of texts to see “below the surface” meanings.

Screen Shot 2021-07-06 at 6.41.03 PM
Screen Shot 2021-07-06 at 6.41.31 PM
Table of Contents

Text Audio

The Landlady by Roald Dahl
Audio File Link
(Youtube link)

Excerpt from Amazing Grace by Jonathan Kozol

McJobs by Eric Schlosser

Writing Tasks

Title: S-3: Reading Ads Like a Detective

Session 3

PDF

Title: S-8: Reading Kozol Like a Detective

Session 8

PDF

Title: S-12: Comprehension Task Retelling Schlosser

Session 12

PDF

Title: S-13: Reading Schlosser Like a Detective

Session 13

PDF

Title: S-16: Reading Like a Detective A Final Assignment

Session 16

PDF

Charts for Discussion

Title: S-2: When We Read Like a Detective, We. . .

Session 2

Title: S-5: Reading Ads Below the Surface

Session 5

Title: S-7: Important or Confusing Moments in “Amazing Grace”

Session 7

Forms and Graphic Organizers

Title: S-1: Tracking “The Landlady”

Session 1

PDF

Title: S-5: Criteria for a Good Discussion

Session 5

PDF